Chapter 17: Comparative Economic Systems

 

 

Command

Communism

Mixed

Socialism

Market

Capitalism

What?

Government

Gov't & Consumer

Consumer

How?

Government

Gov't & Consumer

Consumer

Who?

Government

Gov't & Consumer

Consumer

Examples

Cuba,

former USSR,

North Korea, China

France, Switzerland, Sweden

U.S., Canada, Japan, South Korea

Resource Ownership Government owned and controlled Basic resources government owned Rest are private Privately owned
Resource Allocation Centralized Planning by Gov't Key industries directed by Gov't Market forces

Advantages

Equality for workers

Many public goods provided

Drastic change possible

Little uncertainty

Basic needs met

 

Safety net for non-productive workers

Basic needs met

Market forces used for non-essential goods

Government directed by democratic votes

 

Efficient use of resources

Individual freedom

Limited government

High standard of living

Gradual adjustments possible

Decentralized decision making

Large variety of goods/ services

High consumer satisfaction

Disadvantages

Poor customer satisfaction

Little incentive to work hard

Poor allocation of resources

Inflexible to minor forces

Little initiative and innovation

Little individual freedom

Inefficient bureaucracy

Inefficient

Little incentive to work hard

High tax rates

 

Basic needs unmet

Personal/business uncertainty

Public goods not produced

Poor fit for intangible values (justice, education, health care),

Market failure possible

 

Rise and Fall of Communism

    Karl Marx

        Proletariat

        Bourgeoisie

        Dictatorship of the Proletariat

        Classless society

    Lenin–"From all according to their abilities to all according to their needs"

        Property given to workers

        Production fell

        Money system failed

        Barter economy emerged

    Stalin

        Shift from agricultural to industrial

        Centralized Planning –"Five-Year Plans"

        Collectivization–government ownership of resources

        Brutal enforcement–25 million people killed

    Gosplan

        Five-Year Plans

        Detailed production quotas

        State Farming and Collective farming

        Poor quality consumer goods

    Perestroika

        Reform towards market forces

        Soviet Union collapsed in 1991

        Why?

 

Transition to Capitalism

    Privatization

    Vouchers

    Shift in political power from Communism to Entrepreneurs

    Instability of Capitalism–benefits delayed

    Russia

    Eastern Europe

    Latin America

    China

 

Capitalism Around the World

    Japan

        Heavy government hand

        Worker loyalty

        Capital intensive development

        keiretsu–limit competition

        Closed economy

        High Consumer Prices

    Asian Tigers

        Hong Kong

        Singapore

        Taiwan

        South Korea

    Sweden