Chapter 17:
Comparative Economic Systems
|
|
Command Communism |
Mixed Socialism |
Market Capitalism |
|
What? |
Government |
Gov't & Consumer |
Consumer |
|
How? |
Government |
Gov't & Consumer |
Consumer |
|
Who? |
Government |
Gov't & Consumer |
Consumer |
|
Examples |
former
|
France, Switzerland, Sweden |
|
| Resource Ownership | Government owned and controlled | Basic resources government owned Rest are private | Privately owned |
| Resource Allocation | Centralized Planning by Gov't | Key industries directed by Gov't | Market forces |
|
Advantages |
Equality for workers Many public goods provided
Drastic change Little uncertainty Basic needs met
|
Safety net for
non-productive workers Basic needs met Market forces used for
non-essential goods Government directed by
democratic votes
|
Efficient use of resources Individual freedom Limited government High standard of living Gradual adjustments possible Decentralized decision making Large variety of goods/ services
High consumer satisfaction |
|
Disadvantages |
Poor customer satisfaction Little incentive to work hard Poor allocation
of resources
Inflexible to minor forces
Little initiative
Little individual freedom Inefficient bureaucracy |
Inefficient Little incentive to work
hard High tax rates
|
Basic needs unmet Personal/business uncertainty Public goods not produced
Poor fit for intangible values (justice,
education, health care),
Market failure possible |
Rise and Fall of Communism
Karl Marx
Proletariat
Bourgeoisie
Dictatorship of the Proletariat
Classless society
Lenin–"From all according to their abilities to all according to their needs"
Property given to workers
Production fell
Money system failed
Barter economy emerged
Stalin
Shift from agricultural to industrial
Centralized Planning –"Five-Year Plans"
Collectivization–government ownership of resources
Brutal enforcement–25 million people killed
Gosplan
Five-Year Plans
Detailed production quotas
State Farming and Collective farming
Poor quality consumer goods
Perestroika
Reform towards market forces
Soviet Union collapsed in 1991
Why?
Transition to Capitalism
Privatization
Vouchers
Shift in political power from Communism to Entrepreneurs
Instability of Capitalism–benefits delayed
Russia
Eastern Europe
Latin America
China
Capitalism Around the World
Japan
Heavy government hand
Worker loyalty
Capital intensive development
keiretsu–limit competition
Closed economy
High Consumer Prices
Asian Tigers
Hong Kong
Singapore
Taiwan
South Korea
Sweden